When you sell things on Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace, you have a great opportunity to quickly find your target audience. Each of these platforms has its pros and cons.
Start your online business today – for free.
A fair, garage sale and online store all in one – sites like Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace are becoming a treasure trove of unusual items for many shoppers. They love the feeling of unpredictability – and it’s a great chance for sellers to make money.
Choosing the “right” platform depends on whether you just want to sell unwanted items and make some money or if you plan to develop an online business with sales both locally and globally.
Below is a review of Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist, two of the largest platforms for local sales and resales.
What is Facebook Marketplace?
Facebook Marketplace emerged in 2016 as a service for selling and buying used goods among Facebook users. Initially, the platform focused only on local self-sale transactions, but with the advent of shipping options (especially relevant during the pandemic), Marketplace has become a convenient tool for small businesses, crafters, and part-time hobbyists.
Communication and completion of transactions takes place via Facebook Messenger, and a smart algorithm matches users with personalized offers. In 2025, Marketplace has an audience of about 1.2 billion users – about 40% of Facebook’s total active users.
What is Craigslist?
Craigslist was founded in 1995 by Craig Newmark as a newsletter with San Francisco events. Over time, the site has grown into one of the largest marketplaces for classifieds, jobs, and services. Despite the emergence of competitors, including Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist remains one of the leaders in traffic and revenue.
Visually, the site hasn’t changed much since its launch, although a mobile version was introduced in 2019. The simplicity of the design and lack of advertising creates an atmosphere of a “human voice” on the internet and emphasizes the idea of a community rather than a global corporation.
Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace: a comparison
Key criteria for comparison:
- Delivery options;
- Audience reach;
- Commissions;
- Promotional tools.
Both platforms work on the basis of face-to-face transactions between sellers and buyers, but there are important differences.
Delivery
Craigslist doesn’t offer shipping services – buyer and seller arrange pickup and drop-off.
Facebook Marketplace started with local sales, but now allows you to ship items nationally. This is convenient for those who want to expand beyond the local marketplace or are dropshipping. Shipping deals take a commission, so it’s worth considering it when pricing.
Audience reach
Both marketplaces have millions of users, but Facebook uses AI to show products to exactly those who might be interested. Marketplace also allows you to publish ads in themed groups and choose locations.
On Craigslist, listings need to be updated frequently to stay at the top of the list. Quality photos and descriptions help you stand out, but there are no algorithms for promotion.
Commissions
Listing ads on both platforms is free (except for jobs, services, and real estate on Craigslist, where there is a small fee). Facebook Marketplace only takes a commission for items sent through the platform, no commission for cash transactions.
Promotional tools
There is no paid listing promotion option on Craigslist. Facebook Marketplace offers “Boosted Listings” – the ability to run ad campaigns to increase visibility.
Advantages and disadvantages of Craigslist
Pros:
- Free and easy to use;
- Anonymity – no need to create an account and link sales to social networks;
- Fixed prices – no bidding or auction mechanism, you can stick to your prices.
Cons:
- Less security – minimal user verification;
- Lots of mixed ads, which makes it easy to lose the product in the stream;
- Lack of targeting and promotion algorithms – ads need to be constantly updated for visibility.
Advantages and disadvantages of Facebook Marketplace
Pros:
- Large built-in audience, especially among the younger demographic;
- Mobile-friendliness – you can place an ad in a couple of clicks;
- Personalized offer feed that helps you find buyers faster.
Cons:
- Commissions for shipping transactions have increased to 10%;
- Risks of fraud and bots – you need to be careful;
- Algorithm may limit reach by showing product only to “your” audience.
If you want to start selling online with the possibility of expansion and a convenient tool for promotion – Facebook Marketplace will be a good choice. If it is important to maintain anonymity and minimize commissions – Craigslist is still relevant.